top of page

Are Tampons the Next Major Litigation Risk?

A new study suggests the possibility of a major litigation risk to large U.S. public companies Procter & Gamble Co., Kimberly-Clark Corp. and Edgewell Personal Care Co.




Introduction


A new study suggests the possibility of a major litigation risk to large U.S. public companies Procter & Gamble Co., Kimberly-Clark Corp., and Edgewell Personal Care Co.


A recent study published in Environment International has raised alarming concerns about the safety of tampons, one of the most widely used menstrual hygiene products. The study, conducted by researchers from Columbia University, Michigan State University, and the University of California Berkeley, investigated the presence of metals in tampons and revealed potentially hazardous findings. The study highlights the significant presence of these metals in tampons, posing various health risks through potential systemic absorption.


Chronic exposure to these metals, even at low levels, can have serious long-term health implications. The adverse health outcomes linked to the metals found in tampons, such as lead, cadmium, arsenic, and others, align with several health issues that are observed more frequently or more severely in women. These include reproductive health problems, bone density issues, neurological disorders, cardiovascular diseases, certain cancers, renal disorders, and allergic reactions.


The presence of these metals in menstrual products could be a significant contributing factor to these gender disparities in health outcomes.


These revelations could generate significant litigation risks for manufacturers of major tampon brands including Tampax from Procter & Gamble Co., Kotex from Kimberly-Clark Corp., and Playtex from Edgewell Personal Care Co. This post is our first on what may be an emerging and major litigation risk to these companies.


Study Overview


The study titled "Tampons as a source of exposure to metal(loid)s" aimed to quantify the concentrations of 16 metal(loid)s in a selection of widely available tampons. Researchers analyzed 30 tampons from 14 brands, encompassing 18 product lines, using advanced techniques such as inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS). The metals analyzed included arsenic, barium, calcium, cadmium, cobalt, chromium, copper, iron, manganese, mercury, nickel, lead, selenium, strontium, vanadium, and zinc.


Key Findings


  1. Presence of Toxic Metals: The study found measurable concentrations of all 16 metals in the tampon samples. Notably, toxic metals such as lead (GM = 120 ng/g), cadmium (GM = 6.74 ng/g), and arsenic (GM = 2.56 ng/g) were detected in significant amounts.

  2. Variability Across Products: Metal concentrations varied based on the region of purchase (U.S. vs. EU/UK), organic vs. non-organic materials, and store-brand vs. name-brand products. For instance, lead concentrations were higher in non-organic tampons, while arsenic was higher in organic tampons.

  3. Health Implications: The study highlighted the potential health risks associated with these metals, including neurotoxic effects, reproductive issues, cardiovascular diseases, and increased cancer risk. The vaginal absorption route bypasses the liver's first-pass metabolism, leading to higher systemic exposure to these metals.


Cause for Concern


The presence of metals in tampons, as detailed in the study, poses several potential health risks to women using these products. Here are the specific health risks associated with the metals found in the study:


Lead (Pb)


Lead was found in all samples, with a geometric mean concentration of 120 ng/g. There is no known safe exposure level for lead.


Neurological Effects: Lead exposure, even at low levels, can lead to cognitive impairments, decreased attention, memory issues, and learning disabilities. Chronic exposure can result in more severe neurological damage.


Reproductive Effects: Lead can interfere with reproductive health, causing menstrual irregularities and complications in pregnancy, such as increased risk of miscarriage, preterm birth, and developmental issues in the fetus. Exposure to heavy metals like lead, cadmium, and arsenic can cause reproductive health problems. Studies have shown higher rates of menstrual irregularities and infertility in women exposed to these metals.


Cardiovascular and Renal Effects: Lead exposure is linked to hypertension, cardiovascular diseases, and kidney damage. Women, especially during menopause, are at increased risk of cardiovascular issues, and cumulative metal exposure could be a contributing factor.


Osteoporosis and Fractures: Cadmium and lead can interfere with calcium metabolism, potentially leading to osteoporosis and increased fracture risk. Osteoporosis is more common in women, especially post-menopausal women, which might be linked to cumulative exposure to these metals over time.


Hypertension and Cardiovascular Disease: Lead and cadmium exposure have been linked to hypertension and cardiovascular diseases. Women, especially during menopause, are at increased risk of cardiovascular issues, and cumulative metal exposure could be a contributing factor.


Autoimmune Diseases: Women are more likely to develop autoimmune diseases than men. Some metals, like mercury and lead, have been associated with autoimmune disorders. For example, lupus is 9 times more common in women than men.


Anemia: Exposure to lead can interfere with iron metabolism and contribute to anemia. Iron-deficiency anemia is more common in women of reproductive age.


Cadmium (Cd)


Renal Damage: Cadmium exposure is strongly linked to kidney damage. Chronic kidney disease is seen more frequently in women, and cumulative exposure to cadmium through menstrual products could be a factor.


Bone Health: Cadmium and lead can interfere with calcium metabolism, potentially leading to osteoporosis and increased fracture risk. Osteoporosis is more common in women, especially post-menopausal women, which might be linked to cumulative exposure to these metals over time.


Carcinogenicity: Cadmium is classified as a human carcinogen, with links to cancers of the lung and possibly the breast.


Menstrual Irregularities and Infertility: Exposure to heavy metals like lead, cadmium, and arsenic can cause reproductive health problems. Studies have shown higher rates of menstrual irregularities and infertility in women exposed to these metals.


Pregnancy Complications: Metals such as lead and cadmium are known to cause complications during pregnancy, including preterm birth, low birth weight, and developmental issues in fetuses.


Hypertension and Cardiovascular Disease: Lead and cadmium exposure have been linked to hypertension and cardiovascular diseases. Women, especially during menopause, are at increased risk of cardiovascular issues, and cumulative metal exposure could be a contributing factor.


Thyroid Disorders: Some metals, including cadmium, can interfere with thyroid function. Women are 5-8 times more likely to develop thyroid problems than men.



Arsenic (As)


Carcinogenicity: Inorganic arsenic is a known carcinogen, associated with skin cancer, lung cancer, bladder cancer, and possibly other types.


Cardiovascular Effects: Chronic exposure can lead to cardiovascular diseases, including hypertension and ischemic heart disease.


Dermal and Respiratory Effects: Arsenic exposure can cause skin lesions, hyperpigmentation, and respiratory issues.


Menstrual Irregularities and Infertility: Exposure to heavy metals like lead, cadmium, and arsenic can cause reproductive health problems. Studies have shown higher rates of menstrual irregularities and infertility in women exposed to these metals.


Mercury (Hg)


Neurological Effects: Mercury exposure can cause neurological and behavioral disorders, including tremors, emotional instability, insomnia, memory loss, and neuromuscular changes.


Reproductive Effects: Mercury is particularly harmful during pregnancy, potentially causing developmental issues in the fetus.


Autoimmune Diseases: Women are more likely to develop autoimmune diseases than men. Some metals, like mercury and lead, have been associated with autoimmune disorders. For example, lupus is 9 times more common in women than men.


Chromium (Cr)


Respiratory Effects: Exposure to hexavalent chromium compounds (Cr VI) can cause respiratory problems, including asthma, nasal and sinus cancers.


Dermal Effects: Can cause allergic reactions and dermatitis.


Nickel (Ni)


Dermal Reactions: Nickel can cause allergic contact dermatitis, leading to skin irritation and rashes.


Respiratory and Systemic Effects: Chronic exposure can lead to respiratory issues and is considered a possible human carcinogen.


Manganese (Mn)


Neurological Effects: High exposure can lead to neurotoxicity, with symptoms resembling Parkinson’s disease, such as tremors, difficulty walking, and facial muscle spasms.


Zinc (Zn)


Overexposure: While zinc is essential in small amounts, overexposure can cause nausea, vomiting, loss of appetite, stomach cramps, diarrhea, and headaches.


Copper Deficiency: Excessive zinc can interfere with the absorption of copper, potentially leading to a deficiency.


Cobalt (Co)


Cardiovascular Effects: High levels of cobalt exposure can lead to cardiomyopathy, a condition affecting the heart muscle.


Respiratory and Dermal Effects: Can cause respiratory issues and skin irritation.


Barium (Ba)


Gastrointestinal Effects: High levels of barium can cause gastrointestinal issues, including abdominal pain, vomiting, and diarrhea.


Cardiovascular Effects: Barium exposure can lead to hypokalemia, which affects heart function.


Iron (Fe)


Toxicity: Excess iron can cause gastrointestinal distress, and chronic high levels can lead to organ damage due to iron accumulation.


Selenium (Se)


Toxicity: High levels of selenium can cause selenosis, which includes symptoms like gastrointestinal upsets, hair loss, white blotchy nails, and mild nerve damage.


Vanadium (V)


Respiratory Effects: Inhalation of vanadium can cause respiratory issues, including bronchitis and pneumonitis.


Strontium (Sr)


Bone Health: Strontium can replace calcium in bones, potentially leading to bone weakening and increased fracture risk.


Calcium (Ca)


Balance and Absorption: While calcium is generally beneficial, imbalances can lead to issues with the absorption of other essential minerals.


Copper (Cu)


Gastrointestinal and Liver Effects: High levels of copper can cause gastrointestinal distress and liver damage.


Overall Health Risks


Systemic Exposure: Vaginal absorption bypasses the liver’s first-pass metabolism, leading to higher systemic exposure.


Cumulative Effects: Chronic exposure to multiple metals can have cumulative toxic effects, potentially leading to synergistic interactions that exacerbate health risks.


Breast Cancer: Some studies have suggested a possible link between exposure to heavy metals and an increased risk of breast cancer. The role of environmental toxins, including metals, could be a contributing factor.


Lung Cancer in Non-Smokers: There is a higher incidence of lung cancer among non-smoking women compared to non-smoking men. This disparity could potentially be explained by higher cumulative exposure to toxic metals such as arsenic and cadmium through products like tampons.


Litigation Risks


The findings of this study could expose manufacturers to significant litigation risks on multiple fronts:


  1. Product Liability: Consumers could file lawsuits claiming that tampons caused harm due to metal exposure, leading to potential design defect, manufacturing defect, and failure-to-warn claims.

  2. Consumer Protection: There could be claims under consumer protection laws for misrepresentation and non-disclosure of harmful substances in tampons.

  3. Multi-District Litigation/Class Action: Given the widespread use of tampons, class action lawsuits could emerge, representing large groups of affected consumers, potentially leading to substantial settlements or judgments.

  4. Regulatory Scrutiny: The study may prompt regulatory bodies like the FDA to enforce stricter testing and safety requirements for menstrual products, further increasing compliance costs and liability risks for manufacturers.

  5. False Advertising: If P&G has made any claims about the purity or safety of their tampons, these findings could lead to false advertising claims.


Conclusion


This is a single study and more research is needed to establish whether these metals can actually leach out of tampons and be absorbed by the body in significant amounts. However, the presence of toxic metals, particularly lead, in products used internally could be a significant concern for investors and a potential litigation risk. In future posts, we'll explore a number of topics, including changes in the design and manufacture of female hygiene products after the toxic shock syndrome (TSS) cases in the 1980s. We will also provide financial analysis of the potential impact of this study on the major companies involved in the industry.




25 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page